The good: I loved the story line and it left me in tears (I'm too emotional! haha). The graphics were awesome and the puzzles were challenging. It took me only a day to complete, but it was worth it. I love the details and the visuals. Everything is so beautiful and dark at the same time. Not to mention it was interesting to find more and more about the story and get confused while finding out about what is going on. The bad: I wish it were longer and it didn't end so abruptly. The ending made me go, "What? How can it end like that!" There wasn't really anything besides your imagination to tell what really happened or how the story went all together. No flash backs. No telling what happened right after the ending. But I think this was more based on your imagination as well. Also, they didn't have as many hidden object scenes as I liked. It was more puzzle based and remembering to find an item and then go back to unlock/open things. That's just my opinion.
Other than that, I did enjoy the game and I leave it with a high review, despite some of the things I didn't like.